Referee Charged With Assault After Sideline Incident in Grand Traverse County

Michigan State Police troopers have charged a Michigan High School Athletic Association referee with assault following an October incident at the Traverse Bay Area Youth Soccer Field in Garfield Township. Troopers from the Traverse City Post responded to 1001 Meyer Road at about 6:50 p.m. on Oct. 14 after a reported altercation between referee Randall Smith, 64, and a 16 year old juvenile.

Investigators reported that Smith was running on the sidelines while officiating when he tripped over a juvenile who was standing in front of the team bench. According to the police report, Smith then raised his flag, grabbed the juvenile by the shirt and pushed him over the bench. Troopers submitted their report and supporting evidence to the Grand Traverse County Prosecutor’s Office which resulted in Smith being charged with one count of assault and battery. Smith was arrested on Oct. 28 and was arraigned in 86th District Court. His next scheduled court appearance is Dec. 4.

The filing of a criminal charge against a certified high school official is likely to prompt scrutiny from multiple local institutions that oversee youth sports and public recreation. Parents and coaches often rely on referees to maintain safety and order during games. An allegation that a referee physically assaulted a juvenile on the sideline raises immediate concerns about training, supervision and conduct standards for game officials.

Grand Traverse County residents who attend youth sporting events will want clarity about the policies that govern sideline access, the expectations for referees and the reporting mechanisms available when incidents occur. Local parks and recreation administrators, tournament organizers and the Michigan High School Athletic Association are positioned to review existing protocols and consider whether additional safeguards or mandatory training are needed to prevent similar incidents.

Legally, the assault and battery charge will be resolved through the county court process where prosecutors will present evidence and the defendant will have the opportunity to respond. The outcome could include criminal penalties, administrative action by officiating bodies, or both. The case also highlights the role of law enforcement in responding to disputes at youth events and the necessity of documenting incidents thoroughly when juveniles are involved.

Community members seeking further information can monitor court records at the 86th District Court and contact the Grand Traverse County Prosecutor’s Office for public case details. The Dec. 4 appearance will be the next formal opportunity for the court record to reflect how prosecutors intend to proceed.