Teenager Identified in Knots Landing Death, Investigation Continues

Authorities in Apache County confirmed on November 6, 2025 that human remains located near the Knots Landing community were identified as those of 16 year old Challistia "Tia" Colelay. Colelay had been reported missing on October 16, and the White Mountain Apache Police Department located the remains on November 3. The scene was secured and processed with assistance from federal personnel.

Initial identification relied in part on the clothing and appearance described by investigators. The report notes a pair of size eight and a half black Converse shoes, black and white plaid pants, and a tan shirt. Family members were notified following the identification, according to the police report. Authorities have stated the investigation remains active as they work to determine the circumstances that led to Colelay's death.

The White Mountain Apache Police Department and the Bureau of Indian Affairs posted a joint statement pledging to pursue closure and justice for the family. Local residents can expect visible law enforcement activity in and around the Knots Landing area as investigators continue to gather evidence and interview witnesses. The presence of both tribal police and federal agents underscores the complex jurisdictional environment that often surrounds investigations on tribal lands, where tribal sovereignty and federal responsibilities intersect.

The Bureau of Indian Affairs Missing and Murdered Unit has made a hotline available for anyone with information, at 1 833 560 2065. Community members with tips are also encouraged to contact local dispatch, as coordinated information sharing will be important to the ongoing inquiry. Investigators did not release further details about potential suspects or the precise location of the discovery, citing the active nature of the case.

For residents of Apache County and members of the White Mountain Apache Tribe, the development is a source of grief and concern. Cases involving missing and murdered Indigenous people carry deep historical and cultural ramifications, and the involvement of tribal authorities aims to respect local customs while seeking legal remedies. Community leaders and service providers may mobilize support for the family and for young people who are vulnerable to violence and exploitation.

As the investigation progresses, officials have asked anyone with relevant information to come forward to the BIA hotline or to local law enforcement. The confirmation of Colelay's identity brings urgency to efforts to understand what happened, and to provide answers to a grieving family and a community seeking reassurance and safety.